Exclusive Web Extra: The First Generation Colt Single Action Army

Genesis Of The Colt Single Action:

The First Generation Colt Single Action Army

Part 8 Of A 12-Part Series

By Mike “Duke” Venturino
Photos Yvonne Venturino

Now we get to what can (arguably) be called the “World’s Most Famous Handgun.” Is it? I think so because American western movies have made it to about all corners of the earth. Perhaps people in places like New Guinea, Iceland or Madagascar may not know what handguns those actors are shooting, but I’d bet if a locale has electricity they have seen one sort or another of cowboy movie. Have you ever seen a cowboy movie that didn’t show a Colt SAA or replica?

It might surprise some fans of the Colt SAA that such was not its original name. In the beginning Colt called it their “Strap Pistol.” That was because it was the first of their handguns to have a top-strap over the cylinder. Why was that feature incorporated into the design? Strength! Colt wanted to make this new handgun capable of firing heavier loads. Prior to it their barrels were secured to the main frame only at the bottom. The impact of a big bullet slamming into the barrel could actually cause it to begin to bend away from the frame. A topstrap held it firmly in place.

It might also surprise some fans of the Colt SAA and its most famous chambering, the .45 Colt, that such was not its first caliber. In the early 1870s, prior to the development of the .45 Colt as a cartridge, testing was done with a cartridge the U.S. Army considered its “standard” at that time, Smith & Wesson’s .44 American. Two things intervened: accuracy with that round was not suitable, and the U.S. Army wanted to standardize on .45 caliber for handguns, rifles and carbines. Read that as to standardize on caliber (bore size), not cartridges.

When the first Colt “Strap Pistols” appeared circa November 1873, the new .45 Colt caliber was a milestone. Not only was it exceptionally powerful, with a 250 grain bullet traveling at about 900 fps, but it was Colt’s first cartridge using an inside-the-case, inside-lubed bullet. Prior to the .45 Colt, handgun cartridges such as the .44 Colt and S&W’s .44 American used heel-base bullets.

colt 1

By the 1880s every properly attired American
cowboy felt a Colt SAA revolver was necessary equipment.

Soldier’s Gun

As almost immediately adopted by the U.S. Army for issuing to their cavalry regiments, the .45 Colt “Strap Pistol” came with 7 ½” barrels, one piece walnut grips, with finish consisting of a color case hardened frame, loading gate and hammer. The rest of the revolver was blued. Sights consisted of a very fine blade front with a simple groove down the revolver’s top-strap for a rear sight.

The only safety was a notch on the hammer. When the trigger engaged the notch it held the firing pin away from the cartridge’s primer. It wasn’t much of a safety as evidenced by the fact almost immediately upon receiving their new revolvers cavalry troopers began getting accidentally shot by them. For instance the famous 7th Cavalry received their new Colt .45 revolvers in the summer of 1874 in time to take them along on their expedition to explore the Black Hills of what is now South Dakota. At least one trooper had a stirrup fall and hit the hammer of his new Colt revolver, causing it to discharge. He was fatally wounded in the process.

The new Colt revolvers bought by the U.S. Government for a price of $13.50, including a screwdriver, were all stamped “US” on the left side of their frames. However, government inspectors were very strict and rejected what the Colt firm considered perfectly fine handguns, for minor flaws. As early as 1874, many with that “US” already stamped on the frame were then given a full nickel-plated finish, one piece grips cut of ivory and sold on the civilian market.

colt 2

The Colt SAA revolver was actually developed as a sidearm for U.S. cavalrymen.

Immediate Popularity

Any firearm or caliber adopted by the U.S. Army almost instantly becomes popular in the American civilian market. That was exceptionally true with what by then became known as the Colt Single Action Army. Consider this: by 1892 the U.S. Government had bought only about 37,000 SAAs, but by then the Colt factory had made and shipped a total of 144,000.

Serial numbers of the SAA started with #1 and by 1940, when production ceased for the first time, ended at 357,859. During the early and mid-1870s production, that 7 ½” barrel length dominated. However, the civilian market expressed a desire for shorter lengths. In 1875 a 5 ½” barrel length was made standard.

Along about this time Colt had been honoring special order requests for an even shorter length where the barrel ended about at the end of the ejector rod housing. That was 4 ¾”. That length grew so popular Colt added it as “standard” in 1879. Although Colt shipped custom orders with barrels as short as 2 ½” and as long as 16″, those three lengths were always considered standard after 1879. Without having proof to back up this statement, I think by the time 1st Generation production ceased in 1940, more SAAs were shipped with the 4 ¾” barrel.

colt 3

Although all Colt SAA revolvers sold to the U.S. Government carried this
stamp on the left side of their frames, actually some rejected by government
inspectors were so stamped but sold on the civilian market.

colt 4

By 1879 Colt had settled on these three barrel lengths as their
standard catalog options, although they would accept custom
orders for barrels from 2 ½” to 16″. These are from top 7 ½”, 5 ½” and 4 ¾”.


Chamberings of the Peacemaker (as it also soon to became known) are also an interesting study and far too in depth to be covered here. Sources give about 30 as the total, but in reality only five were made in enough numbers to be considered significant. In order of numbers produced, those were .45 Colt, .44 WCF (.44-40), .38 WCF (.38-40), .32 WCF (.32-20) and .41 Colt, often called .41 Long Colt today. Note that three of the top five Colt SAA calibers actually started out as Winchester lever gun calibers. Here’s one tidbit on this subject. Only the .44 WCF (.44-40) gained its own name in regards to the Colt SAA. Most, but not all Colt Single Action Army revolvers chambered for the .44 WCF, were marked on the left sides of their barrels “Colt Frontier Six-Shooter” or “Frontier Six-Shooter.” No other caliber was so marked.

Although the 1st Generation of Colt SAA, Peacemaker, or Frontier Six-Shooter ended in 1940, the public’s fascination with them did not. They came back and then came back again, as we will cover in future installments.

colt 5

These were the five most popular chamberings of the Colt SAA between
1873 and 1940. From left: .32 WCF (.32-20), .38 WCF (.38-40), .41 Colt,
.44 WCF (.44-40) and .45 Colt.

colt 6

This is a page from a 1936 Colt catalog still showing the Colt SAA in production.

colt 7

Sights on the Colt SAA were merely
a groove in the top-strap for the rear
and thin blade front.

>> Click Here << To View The Genesis Of The Colt Single Action Series

7 thoughts on “Exclusive Web Extra: The First Generation Colt Single Action Army

  1. Hank Daubresse

    You might have mentioned that Colt’s “strap gun” was a near-copy” of Remington’s model 58 design.

    1. colin

      Hello I have a 1893 stamped Colt Frontier Six Shooter not etched. I am thinking about selling it. This Colt 44-40 is in 98% condition with a factory letter. The barrel 4 3/4″ I bought this gun in 1980 from a large colt collector in Florida. Every colt that he had was 95% or better. This piece is one of the best colts that I have ever seen. It is correct 100% from the factory. The blue book shown this non standart model Colt single action Army at $40,000. in 90 % condition. I am asking $25,000. What do you think about this price.?

      Can you give me any help in pricing this fantastic piece.

  2. Bill Schmidt

    First, will this series or articles be available in years to come or do I have to figure out a way of storing them on my computer?

    Second, my .45 SAA, mfg’d c1903, came from the Railway Express Agency in the early 1950s. Their agents carried a variety of revolvers and I was fortunate enough to get some from my father – who retired from REA in 1969 after 51 years. Would you have any records showing how many Colts, especially the SAAs, were purchased by REA?

    Thanks for these informative articles, even though I subscribe to your magazines, I haven’t accessed this website before. I will in the future for certain.

    The articles and pictures are superb.

    Best Regards

  3. john

    Sir, I would like to find out more about the 44 Colt cartridge.I believe S/A Armies were chambered for this cartridge until 1940.I may have the chance to purchase one,which (the owner is adamant it is 44 Long Colt) was sent to the U.K.during WW 2.and has Birmingham Nitro Proof stamps.On page 144 of Keith Cochrans’ book Colt Peacemaker British Model he states serial number 130946 as Colt 44.All other 44 Cals.are designated as W.C/F ,Russian,German or Smith and Wesson.This has Hartford address,Serial Number 345960
    Kind Regards

  4. Bob Wright


    Do you have documentation that the first Colt SAAs were .44 S&W American?

    I have serious doubts.

    Bob Wright

Comments are closed.