Natural Selection
For me, having a bunch of guns has not equaled having a bunch of holsters. My first concealed carry holster was a Crossbreed SuperTuck Inside the Waistband (IWB) model, purchased a little more than nine years ago for a Taurus 24/7. Crossbreed molds the Kydex for their holsters to a particular gun, but that first holster worked for the Taurus for which it was designed, and it was also a good fit for the Stoeger Cougar. When I added a Beretta PX-4 Storm to the arsenal, I was pleased to find it also fit in the original Crossbreed. A couple of years later, I bought a Springfield XDm, my first 45, and was actually surprised to find it rode well in that same Crossbreed Holster, as did a Smith & Wesson M&P, an FNX 40, Sig P226, Sig SP2022 and probably some others I’ve forgotten. One holster, custom molded for one particular handgun, actually worked quite well for a number of other handguns.
I’m sure the holster maker doesn’t want me saying this, as they may think some people might broadly interpret how a gun “fits” into a holster, so take my comments with a grain of salt. I do recommend buying holsters fitted for particular guns, but in my case, a bit of experimenting left me confident the new fits were okay too.
Fast forward a bit. My gun store manager showed me a custom leather holster made by D.M. Bullard Leather Mfg. and suggested we might want to carry them in our gun shop. By then, I’d become a 1911 fan and had a couple of full-size Government Models and several Commanders with 4.25″ barrels. The Government Models both have rails, so I ordered a D.M. Bullard custom leather holster for a Government Model Colt 1911 with rails, and I use that same holster for all seven of my 1911’s. If it fits a gun with a 5″ barrel with a rail, it will work just fine for a 4.25″ barrel with or without a rail.
That D.M. Bullard holster is what they call their Dual Carry holster, which means it can be configured for Inside the Waistband (IWB) or Outside the Waistband (OWB) simply by reversing the belt clips. I like the metal clips, but it can also be ordered with plastic J hooks or leather belt loops allowing for tuckable IWB carry.
The first D.M. Bullard holster worked so well for my 1911’s, I wanted one for my double-stack 9mm’s and .40’s. I chose one custom-molded for a Sig P226. I expected it to work with a Sig P229, Sig M11-A1 and Sig SP2022, but found it also works with my Beretta PX-4, Full-Size M&P, Springfield XDm, FNX-40, SAR K2, CZ-P07 and that original Taurus 24/7. They all fit snugly, providing Level 1 retention. There’s no danger of them falling out, they all draw smoothly and easily, and the holster is incredibly comfortable.